digitalcourage.social is one of the many independent Mastodon servers you can use to participate in the fediverse.
Diese Instanz wird betrieben von Digitalcourage e.V. für die Allgemeinheit. Damit wir das nachhaltig tun können, erheben wir einen jährlichen Vorausbeitrag von 1€/Monat per SEPA-Lastschrifteinzug.

Server stats:

860
active users

#ripples

0 posts0 participants0 posts today

I keep seeing studies (especially computational ones) citing the Ambrose et al. 2016 paper as proof that #HippocampalReplay is modulated by reward.

I don't think this result can be trusted...

  1. The time spent at low-speed at reward sites wasn't controlled. Rats probably left the unrewarded sites much faster, or would move a lot more there than when reward was present.
  2. The amount of ripples or replay is analysed in count per second. I believe this means seconds of any kind of behaviour, not just rest or low speed. But #Ripples and the related #Replay only happens when the rat is quasi-immobile. At low speed you might have 1 replay per second, while when moving it will be 0/s.
  3. A recent preprint (Mallory et al., 2024) suggests that after a few seconds at a reward location, reverse replay dominates. Ambrose et al. specifically show an increase of reverse replay for those more rewarded locations. If rats indeed spent more time at the most rewarded location, they would be in reverse replay mode, fully explaining the results without the need to invoke any kind of value processing.

I might have missed something (if so let me know) but I am now completely unconvinced by the 2016 paper. What do you all think?

linkinghub.elsevier.comReverse Replay of Hippocampal Place Cells Is Uniquely Modulated by Changing RewardHippocampal replays are episodes of sequential place cell activity during sharp-wave ripple oscillations (SWRs). Conflicting hypotheses implicate awak…

Vortex Trapping Of Suspended Sand Grains Over Ripples
--
doi.org/10.1029/2023JF007620 <-- shared paper
--
“KEY POINTS
• Observations of vortex-trapped grains suggest delayed settling of advected grains, as well as delayed advection of grains mobilized from the bed
• Quantitative comparisons of vortex-trapped sand grains compared well with theoretical formulations by Nielsen (1992, doi.org/10.1142/1269) for a forced vortex
• Improved understanding of vortex trapping effects on sediment dynamics may decrease uncertainty in large-scale coastal model predictions..."
#spatial #model #modeling #water #hydrology #hydrodynamics #vortex #sand #sediment #transport #sedimentation #sedimentology #morphodynamics #fluiddynamics #ripples #coast #coastal #research #velocimetry #suspension #experimentation #dynamics #geology #processes #geomorphology #geomorphometry #vortextrapping #sand #grains #flow #ripple #sandwaves #ripples